India Canada Row: India-Canada Relationship In "Deep Crisis, Its Worst  Ever": Experts

  • India–Canada relations witnessed a major setback in Sept 2024 when then PM Justin Trudeau accused India of a “potential role” in the killing of Khalistani separatist Hardeep Singh Nijjar.
  • In Oct–Nov 2024, Canadian NSA Nathalie Drouin and Deputy FM David Morrison admitted to leaking allegations to media, claiming India’s Home Minister was involved in targeting Sikh separatists.
  • India rejected these as absurd, baseless, and politically motivated”, and lodged strong protests.

Recent Developments (2025)

  1. High-Level Talks in Delhi
    • Sept 2025: Canadian NSA Nathalie Drouin & Deputy FM David Morrison visited Delhi.
    • Met India’s NSA Ajit Doval and Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri.
    • Objective → reactivate bilateral dialogue mechanisms and mend strained ties.
  2. Prime Ministerial Understanding
    • G7 Summit (Alberta, 2025): PM Narendra Modi met new Canadian PM Mark Carney.
    • Both sides agreed on a constructive and balanced partnership, resetting relations.
  3. MEA’s Position
    • Reiterated that talks are part of regular bilateral security consultations.
    • Both countries reaffirmed shared values: democracy, rule of law, sovereignty, territorial integrity.
  4. Domains of Cooperation Identified
    • Trade & Investment
    • Defence & Security
    • Energy & Civil Nuclear cooperation
    • Critical Minerals partnership
    • Space & S&T collaboration
    • Agriculture and food security
    • Law enforcement cooperation
  5. Progress Since June 2025
    • Return of High Commissioners to capitals.
    • Restart of structured security consultations.
  6. India’s Security Concerns
    • India raised issue of pro-Khalistan outfits attacking Indian missions in Canada.
    • Stressed → Canada, as host government, must ensure security of diplomatic establishments.

UPSC Relevance

Prelims

  • Key summits: G7, 2025 Alberta (Modi–Carney meet).
  • Bilateral sectors: Critical minerals, energy, defence, space, agriculture.

Mains (GS-II: IR)

  • Challenges: diaspora politics, Khalistan extremism, erosion of trust under Trudeau era.
  • Opportunities: new Canadian leadership under PM Carney, expanding trade & energy partnership, Indo-Pacific collaboration.
  • Themes: sovereignty concerns, role of diaspora in diplomacy, re-engagement of democracies.

Essay Practice

  • “Diaspora as a Bridge or Barrier in Diplomacy: Lessons from India–Canada.”
  • “Rebuilding Trust in Bilateral Relations – The India–Canada Example.”

In Essence

  • India–Canada ties, strained under Trudeau, are now in recovery mode under PM Carney.
  • Positive signs: return of ambassadors, structured dialogue, broad cooperation agenda.
  • Persistent irritant: pro-Khalistan extremism in Canada.
  • Future trajectory depends on whether Canada balances domestic politics with India’s sovereignty and security concerns.